A million-person scan spreads the Big Five across more than 1,200 genetic variants
The average extraversion variant moves a person from the 50th percentile to the 50.35th, which is why the study's lead author says there is no personality gene, and why these numbers say nothing about scoring one individual.
The Scientist · Science desk
What happened
- A Nature paper reports more than 1,200 genetic variants associated with the Big Five personality traits, among them extraversion and conscientiousness.
- The analysis pooled 46 cohorts and over a million mostly European participants, each of whom gave a DNA sample and filled in a personality questionnaire.
- Conscientiousness correlated with lower substance use, more sport and lower-calorie food choices, and more conscientious participants spent less time in hospital.
Why it matters
- What it limits constraint A per-variant effect of 0.35 percentile points forecloses any single-locus test for a trait: the discovery came from the million-person denominator, not from a signal an individual assay could read.
- Who has to decide decision Anyone weighing trait-based inference now has to argue from an aggregate score, and the reported quantity is a per-variant average rather than an accuracy figure for classifying people.
- Who's exposed exposure Because the associations were estimated in a sample described as mostly European, any group outside it is being assessed on borrowed weights whose behaviour there the study does not characterise.
- What it sets up precedent Openness variants predicting cosmopolitan residence sets an interpretive bar for the next personality genetics paper: an association can run through where a person lives rather than through anything in the brain.
Next story · Science · 5h ago
Baker lab's from-scratch zinc proteases cut their chosen target in 36% of 135 designsConfirmed2 publishers
0.35 percentile points is the number to keep. It is the gap between the 50th percentile and the 50.35th, which the study reports as the average effect of one common variant associated with extraversion [3][11]. No personality questionnaire resolves a difference that small.
Signal at that scale is only visible against an enormous denominator, and the design assembles one: 46 cohorts, more than a million participants, each with a DNA sample and a completed questionnaire, which averages upward of 21,700 people per contributing cohort [2][13]. If percentile points simply added, it would take about 143 average-sized variants to carry someone from the median to the top of the distribution [12]. They do not add that way, so read the figure as a scale marker rather than a prediction. The researchers expect thousands more variants beyond the 1,200 they could resolve [6].
A relatives check anchors the design. A variant can look associated with a trait in a population sample because it travels alongside the household that also teaches the behaviour. Comparing results between relatives tests exactly that, and the team reports upbringing is unlikely to explain the associations, while still emphasising the importance of environment [5]. Ted Schwaba of Michigan State University, the lead author, put the headline finding as an absence: no single personality gene, but many variants together adding up to something more sizeable [4].
Openness to experience shows environment working through geography rather than upbringing. Variants linked to openness to experience predicted that a person would live in a more cosmopolitan area, which the researchers note could in turn reinforce the trait [7]. Part of what a personality-associated variant does in this data is predict where somebody ends up.
What is reported is the average effect of a single variant [3], not how well a summed score sorts individuals, and at the outcome end the relationships stay correlational: conscientiousness tracked lower substance use, more sport and a preference for lower-calorie food, and more conscientious people spent less time in hospital and aged more healthily [8]. That behavioural chain is plausible, and it is also the shape in which a trait score, a behaviour and a hospital record can all sit downstream of something the study did not measure. The associations were estimated in a sample described as mostly European [2], and how they behave in other populations is not part of what is reported.
So on the question of a personality gene, this is about as settled as human genetics gets: at least 1,200 loci, with the typical one worth about a third of a percentile point [1][11]. On the question of whether an aggregate score says anything actionable about a particular person, the reported findings supply effect sizes for variants, not accuracy figures for people.
What to watch
- Whether the per-trait within-family effect sizes are published alongside the pooled ones, which would show how much of the 1,200-variant signal survives the household control.
- Replication in cohorts that are not mostly European, since that is the sample the associations were estimated in.
- Any product or institutional screening tool built on these variants, which would have to state individual-level accuracy that the current findings do not report.
Clarity's read
What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.
Reality
- Evidence62
- Adoption
- Not scored
- Hype gap+25
- Incentives35
- Confidence60
Perspective Coverage
3 publishers- Builder
- Builder 55%
- Operator
- Operator 37%
- Investor
- Investor 8%
Claim ledger
Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.
- [1]
Researchers writing in Nature identified over 1,200 genetic variants linked to the Big Five personality traits, including extraversion and conscientiousness.
- [2]
Schwaba and colleagues analysed results from 46 cohorts, together involving over a million mostly European participants, each of whom provided a DNA sample and completed a personality questionnaire.
- [3]
The average effect of a common genetic variant linked to extraversion explained why someone might score in the 50.35th percentile as opposed to the 50th.
- [4]
Ted Schwaba, lead author and faculty at Michigan State University's Department of Psychology, said in a statement that there is no single 'personality gene', but that even though any individual variant makes very little difference, the effects of many variants together can be more sizeable.
- [5]
The team compared relatives' results to determine whether the genetic links were actually the result of upbringing; their results suggest this is unlikely, and they highlight the importance of the environment in shaping personality.
- [6]
The researchers say there could be many thousands more variants beyond the more than 1,200 they identified.
- [7]
Variants linked to openness to experience predicted that a person would live in more cosmopolitan areas, which could in turn reinforce the trait.
- [8]
Conscientiousness was strongly correlated with lower levels of substance use, higher participation in sports and a tendency to choose low-calorie food, and more conscientious people tended to spend less time in hospital and aged more healthily.
- [9]
The Big Five treats personality as five dimensions - extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism and openness to experience - each a spectrum on which a person falls somewhere, rather than a category.
- [10]
The findings highlight how these traits can affect life and health outcomes, from likelihood of being admitted to hospital to preference for an early bedtime.
- [11]
The average per-variant effect for extraversion is 0.35 percentile points.
- [12]
If percentile points added linearly, it would take roughly 143 average-sized extraversion variants to move a person from the median to the top of the distribution.
- [13]
The 46 cohorts averaged more than about 21,700 participants each.
Sources
3 independent publishers whose own reporting we read for this story.
- discovermagazine.comMore Than 1,200 Genetic Variants Linked to Personality Traits Like Extraversion and Conscientiousness
1 article · September 7, 2026
- livescience.com1 million people's genes reveal the heritability of the Big Five personality traits — and it's complicated
1 article · September 10, 2026
- sciencedaily.comYour personality may be more genetic than scientists realized
1 article · September 8, 2026
Topics and entities
Topics
- Behavioral Genetics
- Personality psychology
- Genome-wide association studies
Entities
- Revived Genomics of Personality Consortium
- Michigan State University
- Nature
- Big Five personality traits